When the time comes to your flat roof replacement, selecting the right roofing system is crucial for ensuring longevity, performance, and value. With several options available on the market today, understanding the pros and cons of each can help you make an informed decision that aligns with your budget, climate considerations, and building requirements.
Mid-West Roofing Systems is founded on the principle of getting the most value from your Bismarck, ND commercial roofing investment. Call 701-500-9399 to schedule your flat roof replacement consultation.
Common Flat Roof Systems
Built-Up Roofing (BUR)
Built-Up Roofing, often called “tar and gravel” roofing, is one of the oldest and most reliable flat roof systems. Consisting of alternating layers of bitumen and reinforcing fabrics, BUR creates a finished membrane that’s then topped with an aggregate layer such as gravel or stone.
Advantages:
- Excellent waterproofing and UV protection
- High durability with a lifespan of 15-30 years
- Superior fire resistance
- Low maintenance requirements
Considerations:
- Heavier than other options, requiring stronger structural support
- Installation is labor-intensive and can produce strong odors
Higher installation costs compared to some alternatives
On-Site Estimates!
Modified Bitumen Systems
Modified bitumen roofing is an asphalt-based option enhanced with modifiers like atactic polypropylene (APP) or styrene-butadiene-styrene (SBS) to improve flexibility and weather resistance.
Advantages:
- Good tensile strength and flexibility in cold temperatures
- Can be installed using various methods (torch-applied, self-adhered, or cold-applied)
- Relatively simple to repair and maintain
- Lifespan of approximately 10-20 years
Considerations:
- Torch-down application presents fire hazards during installation
- Susceptible to punctures and tears from foot traffic
EPDM (Rubber) Membrane
Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer (EPDM) is a synthetic rubber membrane widely used for commercial and residential flat roofs.
Advantages:
- Exceptional weather resistance and flexibility
- Simple and quick installation process
- Lightweight and low-impact on building structure
- Long lifespan of 20-30+ years with proper maintenance
- Environmentally friendly option with recyclable materials
Considerations:
- Typically black, which can absorb heat (though white coatings are available)
- More vulnerable to punctures than multi-ply systems
TPO and PVC Membranes
Thermoplastic Polyolefin (TPO) and Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) are single-ply reflective roofing membranes becoming increasingly popular for energy-efficient buildings.
Advantages:
- Highly reflective surface reduces cooling costs
- Strong resistance to UV damage, dirt accumulation, and bacterial growth
- Hot-air welded seams create a monolithic, watertight surface
- Good chemical resistance
- Lifespan of 15-30 years depending on quality and thickness
Considerations:
- Quality can vary significantly between manufacturers
- Installation requires skilled professionals with specific equipment
May cost more initially than some alternatives
Making Your Flat Roof Replacement Decision
When choosing your flat roof system, consider:
- Local climate conditions – Some systems perform better in extreme heat or cold
- Building code requirements – Ensure your selection meets local regulations
- Budget constraints – Balance initial costs with expected lifespan
- Energy efficiency goals – Reflective membranes can significantly reduce energy costs
- Anticipated roof traffic – More durable systems may be needed for frequently accessed roofs
Consulting with several qualified roofing contractors who specialize in commercial and residential flat roofing will provide the most accurate recommendations for your specific situation.
Local Flat Roof Replacement Experts
Selecting the right flat roof replacement system is a significant investment that impacts your building’s protection, energy efficiency, and maintenance requirements for decades to come. Each system offers distinct advantages – from the time-tested durability of BUR to the energy-saving benefits of TPO and PVC membranes. Consider your building’s structural capacity, local weather patterns, and long-term maintenance plans when making your decision.
Remember that proper installation is just as important as the material you choose. Working with certified installers who specialize in your selected roofing system ensures that manufacturer warranties remain valid and that your roof performs as expected throughout its lifespan. By carefully weighing the characteristics of each system against your specific needs and budget, you’ll be well-equipped to make a choice that provides reliable protection and value for years to come.
To learn more about the systems available for your Bismarck, ND flat roof replacement project, call 701-500-9399 and speak with an expert.
FAQ
How long do flat roof systems typically last?
The lifespan of flat roof systems varies by material: BUR systems typically last 15-30 years, modified bitumen 10-20 years, EPDM rubber membranes 20-30+ years, and TPO/PVC membranes 15-30 years. Proper installation, regular maintenance, and local climate conditions all impact longevity.
What is the most cost-effective flat roofing system?
While modified bitumen and EPDM systems often have lower initial installation costs, TPO and PVC membranes may offer better long-term value through energy savings and durability. The most cost-effective solution depends on your specific building requirements, climate, and energy usage patterns.
Can I install a new flat roof over an existing one?
In some cases, you can install a new flat roof system over an existing one, which can reduce removal costs and minimize disruption. However, building codes often limit the number of roof layers allowed, and the existing roof must be structurally sound and dry. A professional roof inspection is essential before deciding on this approach.
What maintenance do flat roofs require?
All flat roofs benefit from bi-annual inspections (spring and fall), keeping drains and scuppers clear of debris, prompt repair of any punctures or damage, and regular cleaning. Different materials have specific maintenance needs: EPDM may need resealing at seams, while TPO and PVC benefit from periodic washing to maintain reflectivity.
Which flat roof system is best for energy efficiency?
TPO and PVC membranes with high solar reflectivity are the most energy-efficient options for buildings in sunny climates, potentially reducing cooling costs by 20-30%. For colder regions, dark-colored EPDM may be preferable for heat absorption during winter months. Many systems can be enhanced with additional insulation to improve overall building energy performance.